How politicians are robbing NJ’s public schools to reward charter schools

Where did the money go?
Where did the money go?

Christopher Cerf–the state-appointed Newark schools superintendent, former state education commissioner, national charter champion and failed business entrepreneur–has scheduled a forum Thursday night from 6 pm to 8 pm at the Park Elementary School to offer his version of where the money went.


It might be a good time for city residents to ask about the shift of funds from public schools to charter schools–and his staff’s tampering with special education reporting documents.


The city school district, after 20 years of state control, faces a year-end shortfall of some $20 million. Cerf already has ordered cuts of up to 75 percent in what’s left of neighborhood school budgets. Charter school budgets, however, remained untouched.


At the last school board meeting, students from a variety of schools talked about cuts in services and supplies as Cerf looks for a way to cover up the fiscal mismanagement that occurred under the leadership of the woman he appointed to be Newark superintendent–Cami Anderson.

But, when Cerf appeared before the state school board Wednesday, you’d think Newark was the best-run school district in New Jersey. He justified robbing public schools to fund charter schools because, he said, the charters faced “catastrophic” consequences.


Anderson has blamed much of the shortfall on the district’s own strategies to expand charter school enrollment while closing neighborhood schools–strategies clearly designed to replace traditional public schools with the privately-operated charter schools that are clearly favored in the districbution of public funds. Cerf conceded such policies were not “thought through”–but who needs to think through policies that injure poor children?

Let’s go back and review just how badly the state shafted public schools to reward politically-connected charters:

Leaders of Save Our Schools–New Jersey have suggested that Newark residents review just how the charters were allowed to rob traditional public schools of nearly $70 million in state aid–more than enough to cover the shortfall.


They published this in June: “The Education Law Center confirms that the NJ democratic leadership has chosen to transfer $37.5 million from district to charter schools, funding charter schools at higher levels than required by the charter law while shorting districts for the 7th year in a row.


“We are hearing that the language that Governor Christie put into the FY 2016 budget, that violates NJ’s school funding formula and charter law by diverting $37.5 million from local district public schools to charter schools, is staying in the version of the state budget that the democrats are voting on today.


“If this is true, then the democratic leadership – particularly Senator President Steve Sweeney who has the final word on such matters – is consciously choosing to fund charter schools beyond what the charter law stipulates, at the expense of already underfunded district public schools.


“Equally telling is the fact that Senate Education Committee Chair Teresa Ruiz, who represents Newark and is on the Senate Budget Committee, could not or would not help the Newark district schools hold on to the $25 million of this $37.5 million that this budget language will shift from Newark District to Newark charter schools. Newark District schools lost an additional $38 million to Newark charter schools in 2014-15 through a similar budget maneuver.”


SOS-NJ then added this:   “New Jersey local public school students lost 107.6 million dollars as a result of a budget trick created by the Christie Administration but allowed to stay in this year’s budget by NJ’s democratic legislative leadership.




“VERY! As an example, each child attending local public schools in Newark lost more than $2,000 in funding.




“The money taken from local public school budgets was distributed to 96 charter schools (the amounts each charter school received are detailed in this just released analysis prepared by the nonpartisan Office of Legislative Services).



“Almost $17 million went to just 5 charter schools:

“1) North Star (Uncommon charter network) $6,826,724


2) TEAM (KIPP charter network) $5,414,406

3) Marion P. Thomas charter school $2,250,071

4) Robert Treat charter school $1,051,282

5) Newark Legacy charter school $1,144,664

Save Our Schools New Jersey's photo.
Save Our Schools New Jersey's photo.
Save Our Schools New Jersey's photo.
Save Our Schools New Jersey's photo.












The charter schools are gearing up for a war that would take even more money from neighborhood public schools. At the same time, the pro-public school forces–in Newark, in any event–have all but withdrawn form the field as a consequence of a deal between Mayor Ras Baraka and Gov. Chris Christie that is supposed to bring local control to the city schools after 20 years of state control.

  1. One part your leaving out is each charter school pay for every child that is in there school where is that money going. They pay for the buildings they are in. Where is all that money going

    Bob Braun: It should be noted that, in some cases, charter schools pay rent to corporations made up of the same people who run the charter schools. Some of those corporations–like Pink Hula Hoop–are organized as profit-making corporations.

    1. Most charter schools in newark are in nps buildings and that money goes directly to nps

      Bob Braun: But not at fair market value–just as Cami Anderson/Christopher Cerf (a former trustee at KIPP) sold the 18th Avenue School to KIPP at less than fair market value.

  2. Left wing, right wing, same damn turkey….I am not surprise how the Democrats have allowed this to happen. Unfortunately, “we the people”, do not have a political party that we can trust. In addition, the “When I become Mayor, We become Mayor” was a joke from the start – Ras played those who thought that he was for the people of Newark. Smh.

  3. Defund public schools. Create chaos among the children, families, and teachers in those public school. Create insecurity and false scarcity to stoke a competitive war among parents to send the most motivated kids to private Charter schools, skimming the highest performing kids from them. Allow charters to select enrollments and dodge the most challenged kids who need the most resources, concentrating them in public schools.

    And then blame the public schools for failure and justify more Charter schools.

    Disgraceful game plan.

  4. It’s interesting that high on the list of charter schools receiving the most state funds is Robert Treat, founded by political boss (and Christie supporter) Steve Adubato and run by his daughter.

    1. Is there any example of political nepotism and cronyism bigger than Steve Adubato and the Adubato family political family connections?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.